2022’s Best Cities for Farmers Markets in Winter Months

Two young women at a farmers market during colder weather months

Winter can freeze farmers markets — from operating, that is — as the days get shorter in some parts of the country. Fortunately, many stay open so patrons can keep buying locally grown produce and unique goods all season long. 

So, which cities offer the best access to farmers markets between November and March?

Lawn Love compared 101 of the biggest U.S. cities to rank 2022’s Best Cities for Farmers Markets in Winter Months, separated by warm and cold climates.

We looked for walkable cities with good weather and, of course, plenty of winter markets to visit throughout the season. 

Use our rankings, in-depth analysis, and expert insights to make the most out of your next artisanal excursion. 

In this article

  1. Cold city rankings
  2. Warm city rankings
  3. Infographic: Cold vs. warm cities
  4. Results in depth
  5. Expert take
  6. Methodology
  7. Final thoughts: Local market landmarks

Cold city rankings 

See how each city fared in our ranking:

Warm city rankings 

See how each warm city fared in our ranking:

Infographic: Cold vs. warm cities

infographic depicting a map and percentages of the best cities for winter farmers markets
Note: A total of 17 cities tied for first place in Number of Very Cold Days. However, only five are shown in the above infographic for presentation purposes.

Results in depth

Freezing festivities 

A chill in the air won’t stop residents in cold cities from braving the weather to support their local farmers markets. 

New York takes the top spot in our cold cities ranking. In the Big Apple, there are plenty of winter markets to walk to, giving New Yorkers a chance to make the big city feel small by connecting with farmers, artisans, and other members of their community.

Following close behind is Portland, Oregon (No. 2), unsurprising due to the city’s vibrant communities, commitment to sustainability, and award-winning artisanal goods like beer

Philadelphia (No. 3) is even more walkable and has been loving its local farmers and artisans for more than a century

Local tip: NYC’s iconic Union Square Greenmarket is open year-round, four days a week, bringing fresh food, flowers, and more to the heart of Manhattan. Frequented by more than 60,000 customers per day, this is one of the most popular farmers markets in the country. 

In Portland, stop by People’s Farmers’ Market — the longest-running market in the city that operates year-round — to see live music, watch cooking demos, and get to know your neighbors. 

Trendy and tropical tastes

Cities with tropical climates have a big advantage when it comes to fresh produce: Their growing season never ends. 

Sunny Los Angeles (No. 1) tops our warm cities ranking. The city boasts plenty of markets with unique stalls selling items like thrifted clothes, vintage records, and used books. Los Angeles’ abundance of markets and high walkability earned the city a 10-point lead on the next warm city.

The island of Oahu is known as “The Gathering Place,” so it’s no wonder that its main city, Honolulu (No. 2), has plenty of opportunities to gather at neighborhood farmers markets. Honolulu’s markets offer fresh fruit you won’t find in most other city markets, such as guava, breadfruit, and longan. 

Almost 5,000 miles away, Miami takes third place, with local farmers selling fresh vegetables in the sun all winter long. 

Local tip: With origins dating back to 1880, L.A.’s Original Farmers Market is open daily year-round. During the holiday season, the market holds special winter events like live music, comedy, and crafting.

At the Honolulu Farmers Market, you can find a diverse range of foods sourced from ingredients grown right in Hawaii, including Hawaiian-style chili, hibachi, boba, takoyaki balls, and more. 

Walking in a winter wonderland

Pedestrian-friendly cities pave a smooth path toward the farmers markets in our cold cities ranking, where most of the top 10 cities also scored in the top 10 for walkability.

Though patrons might need to bundle up, residents of top-ranking cities like Washington, D.C. (No. 4), Chicago (No. 5), and Providence, Rhode Island (No. 6), can easily stroll to winter markets in their area. 

By prioritizing walker-friendly infrastructure, these cities encourage their residents to lead a healthier, more active lifestyle, which is especially important in colder seasons when people tend to stay indoors more often. 

Local tip: In D.C., stop by Eastern Market, a historic public market built into the original city plans that has been operating since 1873. Operating both indoors and outdoors, you can find a variety of produce, prepared foods, and artisanal goods year-round. 

Chicago’s Green City Market has some of the strictest guidelines for vendor sustainability in the U.S., making it a trusted and beloved market for environmentally conscious Chicagoans.

In Providence, stay cozy by visiting the Farm Fresh Providence Farmers Market, an indoor market on the edge of the Woonasquatucket River designed to allow customers to keep their distance and stay safe during the pandemic. 

Coasting through the markets

Walkability doesn’t seem to be as much of a concern for warmer cities like Houston (No. 4), San Diego (No. 5), or San Antonio (No. 6). 

These cities placed higher than some of the more pedestrian-friendly cities like New Orleans (No. 23). Houston and San Antonio pulled ahead, thanks to their high number of farmers markets, while San Diego got a boost from its lovely weather.

All three cities are booming in population and have each begun to take steps to improve pedestrian access. Houston has a Walkable Places Committee, San Diego is implementing Pedestrian Area Plans, and San Antonio created an ongoing SA Tomorrow Comprehensive Plan

Local tip: Houston’s weekly Urban Harvest Farmers Market brings in more than 100 vendors from within a 180-mile radius of the city limits. Urban Harvest also organizes a community garden program and hosts gardening education and certification programs. 

Each week, San Diego’s Little Italy Mercato fills six blocks downtown with stalls selling fresh produce, gourmet olive oil, and artisanal bread.

Pearl Farmers Market is a beloved local spot in San Antonio. Hosted outside of The Pearl, a former brewery, all vendors operate within 150 miles of the city, giving the market a uniquely Texan flair.

Expert take

While the harvest season may end in autumn, people still need to eat, and farmers still have bills to pay. But what are the other benefits of keeping farmers markets open through the winter? We turned to some experts to find out: 

  1. What are the top three ways farmers markets benefit their communities?
  2. What are three reasons why consumers should buy from farmers markets over their local supermarket?
  3. What should consumers know about shopping at farmers markets during the winter?
  4. What are the top three benefits of keeping farmers markets operating through the winter to farmers, consumers, and/or the local economy?
  5. What kinds of products (or potential gifts) might consumers find at winter farmers markets that they normally wouldn’t find during the warmer seasons?

Ask The Experts

Dr. Audrey Guskey
Dr. Audrey Guskey
Professor
Subbu Kumarappan, PhD
Subbu Kumarappan, PhD
Associate Professor
Dawn Thilmany McFadden
Dawn Thilmany McFadden
Co-Director, CSU Regional Economic Development Institute, Professor, Ag and Resource Economics
Luke Gocke
Luke Gocke
Instructor
Wandra Arrington
Wandra Arrington, PhD
Assistant Professor, School of Agriculture and Applied Sciences
Rebekka Dudensing
Rebekka Dudensing, Ph.D.
Associate Professor & Extension Economist – Community Economic Development, Department of Agricultural Economics

Methodology

We ranked 101 of the biggest U.S. cities, split into cold cities and warm cities, determined by the mildness of their states’ winters.

Cold cities were ranked from best to worst (1-60), as were warm cities (1-41), based on their overall scores (out of 100 points), averaged across the weighted metrics listed below. 

For the Winter Farmers Markets data, we counted USDA-registered farmers markets operating at least once between November and March. The USDA directory relies on self-reported information from farmers market managers, and therefore may not include all farmers markets in the city that operate during winter.

Access

  • Winter Farmers Markets (Weight: 3)

Walkability

  • Walk Score (Weight: 2)

Climate

  • Average Rain (Inches) in Winter (Weight: 1)
  • Number of Very Cold Days in Winter (Weight: 1)
  • Average Sunshine in Winter (Weight: 1)

Sources

National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, U.S. Department of Agriculture, and Walk Score

Final thoughts: Local market landmarks

Don’t go into hibernation this winter — get some fresh air and food by visiting your local farmers market. 

Learn about seasonal fruits and vegetables, find unique artisanal goods, and experience something new. Many farmers markets host unique events, such as live music and cooking demonstrations, which aren’t available at most local supermarkets.

If your local farmers market is lackluster at best, why not take a trip to an iconic farmers market near you? Here’s what you’ll find at some of America’s most notable farmers markets:

  • Seattle, Washington: In 1907, Pike Place Market opened as the first farmers market in Seattle and has since risen to landmark status. Many know of it as the place where Starbucks originated, but to Seattleites, Pike Place is so much more. Open daily throughout the year, Pike Place Market is a space for finding fresh food, artisanal goods, art, and community events, including holiday season kickoff, Magic in the Market.
  • Cleveland, Ohio: West Side Market has become a significant landmark in Cleveland since its humble beginnings as a street market in 1840. The market’s iconic clock tower was built in 1912, and the site was added to the U.S. National Register of Historic Places in 1973.
  • Madison, Wisconsin: The Dane County Farmers’ Market is the largest producer-only farmers market in the country, meaning that every product for sale has been grown or made in Wisconsin by the vendor selling it. This makes it easy for farmers to connect with their customers, and for consumers to access information about what they’re buying directly from the source. 
  • Detroit, Michigan: The historic Eastern Market has origins dating back to 1841, and the Eastern Market Historic District was added to the National Register of Historic Places in 1978. The market occupies more than 43 acres of space, and is home to the largest open-air flowerbed market in America. 
  • Lancaster, Pennsylvania: Lancaster was officially designated a “market town” by King George II in 1742, but the city’s Central Market has a history dating back even further to the 1730s. Central Market is the oldest continually operating farmers market in the United States. If you get the chance to go, be sure to check out Stoner’s Homegrown Vegetables, a market stand that’s been operating for more than a century.

Main Photo Credit: Shutterstock

Sav Maive

Sav Maive is a writer and director based in San Antonio. Sav is a graduate from the University of Virginia and is a loving cat and plant mom.