What Are the Pros and Cons of Peat Moss?

close-up of bright green peat moss

If you are new to gardening, you’ve probably heard of peat moss but don’t know a lot about it. Peat moss comes from decomposed sphagnum moss found underwater in peat bogs. Many gardeners add peat moss to their soil because it works wonders for some plants, but other gardeners avoid this common soil amendment like the plague. 

Once you learn the pros and cons of peat moss, you’ll understand why it sparks controversy in gardening circles (especially eco-conscious ones). Should you stop using peat moss? You’ll have to weigh the pros and cons for yourself.

Pros of peat moss for the garden

Peat moss is a common ingredient in potting mixes, and many gardeners add it to their garden soil, too. Its popularity is all thanks to the many benefits of peat moss for improving soil quality. 

✓ Absorbs and retains water

Peat moss can hold several times its weight in water. It helps soil retain moisture longer. What does that mean for you? You don’t have to water your plants as often, and they’ll still have all the water they need. 

Even though it retains water, peat moss prevents soil from becoming too water-logged because it releases moisture slowly. Peat moss has the best of both worlds: It holds sufficient water for plants while still having good drainage. 

✓ Prevents soil compaction

illustration showing good soil vs compacted soil

Peat moss is lightweight and has a loose texture, so it doesn’t get compacted over time as heavy soil does. 

When soil becomes compacted, water and nutrients can’t get through to your plants’ roots. Your plants can die as a result. One way to solve this problem is lawn aeration. But with peat moss, your soil will be looser, and you won’t have to aerate as often. 

✓ Holds soil nutrients

Did you know essential nutrients (such as nitrogen, phosphorus, and potassium) can leach out of your soil when you water your plants? Peat moss helps prevent this nutrient loss. Just like it holds water, it holds onto those nutrients better than soil does on its own. 

If your soil retains more nutrients, plants can grow strong and healthy without as much fertilizing

✓ Free of bacteria, fungi, and weed seeds

Before they ship peat moss to stores, producers have to sterilize it. Because peat moss is completely sterile, it’s free of bacteria, fungi, and weed seeds that could harm your plants. Other organic matter (compost, for example) carries the risk of contaminating your soil with these pathogens.

Sterility is a great quality in a seed starter. Seedlings are extremely vulnerable, and they need a clean, safe environment in which to establish themselves. Peat moss provides that environment.

✓ Lasts several years 

The process of peat moss decomposing takes place in a bog, underwater, without oxygen. In these anaerobic (oxygenless) conditions, peat moss takes centuries to break down.

Peat moss continues to break down at this slow pace in your soil, which means it lasts a lot longer than other organic materials. One application of peat moss will benefit your soil for two years or more. 

✓ Perfect for acid-loving plants

Peat moss is acidic, and adding it to your soil will make the soil more acidic, too. That’s great news for any plants that thrive at an acidic pH. 

Plants that need acidic soil and could benefit from an application of peat moss include (but are not limited to):

  • Blueberry bushes
  • Azaleas
  • Camellias
  • Hydrangeas 
  • Irises
  • Dogwood trees

Cons of peat moss for the garden

If peat moss sounds too good to be true, that’s because it just might be. There are some things peat moss can’t do for your soil. Plus, many gardeners refuse to use it because peat moss mining is bad for the environment. 

✗ Non-renewable resource

In nature, peat bogs are a type of carbon sink, which means they absorb more carbon than they release. Carbon sinks help regulate the amount of carbon dioxide in the air and slow global warming.

When humans mine peat bogs for peat moss, they take away from that carbon sink effect. And since peat bogs gain less than a millimeter in depth every year, they’re considered a non-renewable resource. That means once we mine the last of them, they’re gone (at least for several human generations). 

Even if peat moss producers try to repair some of the damage after mining, a mined peat bog may never return to its former, natural self. Every time peat moss is mined, we inch closer to running out of this valuable resource for our planet. 

✗ Contributes to climate change 

Peat moss mining is bad for the environment in another way: It releases carbon emissions into the air. Carbon emissions contribute to climate change and global warming. 

According to the United Nations, peatlands (another word for peat bogs) are the world’s largest holder of organic soil carbon, and they contain almost 100 times more carbon than tropical forests. When peat moss producers drain peatlands, they release a lot of that carbon into the atmosphere.

✗ Expensive 

Most peat moss sold in the United States comes from peat bogs in Canada. Since it has to be shipped internationally, peat moss is more expensive than other organic soil amendments such as compost or pine bark. 

Compare these prices of organic soil amendments (based on pricing from Lowe’s at the time of this publication):

*per cubic foot
Peat moss$4.33
Pine bark$1.74

✗ Poor in beneficial nutrients

Even though peat moss can help your soil retain nutrients, it hardly contains any nutrients at all in and of itself. You could call it infertile. 

Peat moss doesn’t add sufficient nutrients to the soil for healthy plant growth on its own, so you usually have to add other soil amendments along with it. Gardeners often add manure or fertilizer along with peat moss. 

✗ Too acidic for some plants

Remember when we said peat moss is perfect for acid-loving plants? There’s a downside to that, too. Peat moss can make the soil too acidic for plants that need an alkaline or neutral soil pH. 

Before using peat moss in your garden, find out if your plants can tolerate acidic soil. Otherwise, you might end up killing them. 

Uses for peat moss

Peat moss makes a good soil amendment for some gardens, but it has other uses, too.

Some of the best uses of peat moss are:

  • Potting mixes: Peat moss is the main ingredient in many potting soils because it helps so much with drainage. Plants in containers often have problems with waterlogged soil, which peat moss helps prevent. 
  • Seed starting: Because it’s sterile, peat moss is one of the best seed-starting mediums. You can purchase small peat moss pellets to insert into the soil where you want to plant seeds.
  • Hydroponic growing: In hydroponic growing (aka soilless growing), you have to use a growing medium other than soil to support the roots of the plants. Peat moss mixed with perlite or vermiculite is a common choice because it holds water and nutrients but still has good drainage.

Environmental proponents recommend only using peat moss in smaller quantities for these purposes instead of adding a large amount to your whole garden. 

Peat moss alternatives

Have you decided not to use peat moss in your garden because you’re concerned about the environmental impact? There are more eco-friendly organic materials that can achieve some of the same goals.    

These alternative organic soil amendments aren’t exactly like peat moss, but they do the trick:

  • Compost: Compost is inexpensive and readily available. Like peat moss, it helps the soil retain water and nutrients. It also adds nutrients, which gives it an advantage over peat moss. 
  • Coconut coir, aka coco coir: Coco coir is a byproduct of harvesting coconut fibers. It’s similar to peat moss in many ways: It retains moisture, loosens the soil, and takes a long time to break down.
  • Pine bark: Finely ground pine bark in your soil prevents it from becoming compacted and helps retain moisture. For a soil amendment, you want pine bark soil conditioner, not pine bark nuggets, which are used for mulch. 
  • PittMoss: PittMoss is a locally sourced, eco-friendly brand of potting mix and soil conditioner made of recycled paper. This product was designed to replace peat moss (thus the clever name), and it has many of the same effects on soil. 
  • Worm castings: Worm castings (sometimes called vermicast) come from earthworms. They improve soil texture and add nutrients as a fertilizer. 

You can find these peat moss alternatives online and at many garden centers such as Lowe’s and Home Depot. 

FAQ about peat moss

1. What’s the difference between peat moss and sphagnum moss?

The difference between “peat moss” and “sphagnum moss” when we’re talking about garden supplies is tricky.

Sphagnum moss is the live moss that grows in peat bogs. It’s harvested while still alive. People use sphagnum moss to decorate potted plants or to line wire baskets for planting. Sphagnum moss that was harvested while alive isn’t a soil amendment like peat moss. 

Peat moss is sphagnum moss that’s been dead and decomposing underwater for centuries. Through that decomposition process, it becomes useful for your soil. 

2. Where can I find peat moss?

You can find peat moss at most garden centers (including Lowe’s and Home Depot). 

Most often, you’ll find peat moss sold in small quantities in bags. When in bulk, it usually comes in bales or bricks wrapped in plastic. Sometimes, the product label will read “sphagnum peat moss.” 

3. Why is peat moss being banned?

The United Kingdom’s government will ban the use of peat moss for home gardeners beginning in 2024 in an effort to preserve the country’s peatlands. According to the UK’s Environment Secretary George Eustice, the ban is happening because “Peatlands are our biggest terrestrial carbon store and home to some of our rarest species.”

There are currently no plans to ban or restrict the use of peat moss in the United States (or anywhere else other than the UK, based on our research).

4. Can I use peat moss as mulch?

No, peat moss doesn’t make a good mulch, even though the package label may list mulching as a potential use. Here’s why peat moss makes a bad mulch material:

It’s so lightweight that the wind will easily blow it away. 
It isn’t very effective at suppressing weeds.
It won’t add any nutrients to the soil as it breaks down, which is one of the main appeals of organic mulch. 

5. What’s the ratio for mixing peat moss with soil?

If you decide peat moss soil is right for your garden, mix it at a ratio of 2 parts soil to 1 part peat moss.

6. Do succulents like peat moss? 

Yes. Peat moss helps improve soil drainage and prevent soggy soil, which is great for succulents. 

7. Is peat moss a fertilizer?

No. Peat moss can help your soil retain nutrients and encourage your plants to grow healthier, but it barely contains any nutrients on its own.

8. Should you use peat moss in your garden?

Peat moss might seem great because of all its benefits for your soil, but it isn’t right for everyone. Don’t use peat moss in your garden if:

Your plants need alkaline soil
You believe in eco-friendly gardening practices
You want a soil amendment that will add nutrients to your soil 

If you don’t want to use peat moss for any of these reasons, try making your own backyard compost instead. Compost is great for the environment, it won’t affect soil pH level, and it’s rich in vital nutrients for your plants. 

Just like peat moss can breathe new life into your soil, regular lawn maintenance from one of our local pros can breathe new life into your grass — without the massive carbon footprint. 

Main Photo Credit: Jessa and Mark Anderson | Flickr | CC BY 2.0

Jordan Ardoin

Jordan Ardoin is a writer and editor with a passion for sustainable, earth-friendly gardening and lawn care practices. When she isn't sharing her knowledge about lawn care and landscaping, you can find her curled up with a good book and a cat in her lap.